Non-5picks

Double Take's sweet and spicy signature sauce, featuring a base of roasted red bell peppers, carrots, and onion, with a pepper blend of Ancho, Haba...

This citrusy sauce features mango, tamarind, Cayenne and lime juice, an ode to the Guatemalan tradition of mango con chile y limón. Heat Level: Mil...

This sauce highlights the unique flavors of a trio of Peruvian peppers, Limo, Rocoto and Aji Amarillo. The citrusy bright flavor of the peppers is ...

Formosa is known for their creamy sauces, and their latest creation is no exception, with a luscious consistency and just enough Ghost Pepper to ad...

An aerospace engineer turned his sights to hot sauce and created this flavorful pepper-forward blend of Habanero and Serrano peppers, with aromatic...

A well balanced Louisiana style sauce made with Orange Habanero and Cayenne peppers, along with distilled and white wine vinegar for plenty of tang...

A multi-award winning take on soy sauce, with a medium kick and a delicious twist of sweetness. Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Soy Sauce (water, w...

An incredible collaboration from High Desert Sauce Co and Craving Capsaicin, this sauce blends fire roasted tomatoes with Habanero, Reaper, and Jal...

A complex and earthy sauce made with caramelized onions and black garlic, with tang from balsamic vinegar, sweetness from blackberry juice, and a m...

Coleman’s hottest offering yet, this sauce puts the heat and flavor of the Carolina Reaper on full display, with a classic backdrop of vinegar and ...

Coleman’s mildest sauce, it features the clean flavor of Cayenne peppers front and center, with plenty of tang from white wine vinegar and lemon ju...

Apple Caraway is balanced with sweetness from dates and apple, fresh pepper flavor, and the depth of caraway. It's a great medium heat sauce with a...

A nice hearty Habanero sauce made in Utah, with plenty of body from carrots, onion, and garlic, along with tang from a blend of lemon, lime, and ci...

A spooky combination of Ghost, Cayenne, and Red Habaneros, with plenty of garlic and a secret blend of Cajun spices to round it out.  Heat Level: E...

A flavor bomb inspired by the bold kick of Chinese take-out mustard. This blend amplifies the heat and intensity, delivering a fiery punch that wil...

The hottest sauce from Fresco Sauce Co, Arbol Scorpion combines fruity Scorpion peppers, rich pomegranate juice, grassy Arbol chili, and earthy ann...

Mellow Vibes Only Hot Sauce is the milder sibling of Butterfly Bakery's fiery Taco Vibes Only hot sauce. It balances serrano and sweet peppers with...

A blazing upgrade to Gator Jake's Rajun Cajun, this sauce brings in fiery 7-Pot Primo peppers to deliver some serious heat along with the classic C...

This sauce features vibrant curry spices, a healthy serving of roasted garlic, and enough Habanero to provide a kick without overwhelming the other...

Get a taste of San Diego with this rich, smoky Chipotle sauce. The mellow kick is paired with plenty of garlic and rounded out with a vinegar tang....

Created in Oceanside, California, this sauce has a garlic-forward flavor, with smoky hints of Paprika and the slow building heat of Ghost Peppers. ...

Datil peppers are a citrusy yellow pepper known for being grown in St. Augustine, Florida. This sauce combines fermented Datil mash with fresh and ...